COPE, with Idiocy

The climate and evolution standards are just two aspects of a set of guidelines containing hundreds of new ideas on how to teach science. But they have already drawn hostile commentary from conservative groups critical of mainstream scientific thinking.

For instance, as the standards were being drafted, a group called Citizens for Objective Public Education, which lists officers in Florida and Kansas, distributed a nine-page letter attacking them. It warned that the standards ignored evidence against evolution, promoted “secular humanism,” and threatened to “take away the right of parents to direct the religious education of their children.”

— NYT: New Guidelines Call for Broad Changes in Science Education

More Intelligent Design for Evolution

Evolution is generally a good app, so the e-mail account configuration assistant sticks out. Unfortunately, it is the first thing users encounter after first launching Evolution.

    1. First, a pointless welcome message that refers to the Assistant by a name different from the window title.
    2. It appears that prime marks rather than quotation marks enclose “Forward”. This typographical mistake appears throughout the Assistant.


  1. Poorly wrapped instructional text.


  2. “None” is not a sensible default for an incoming server type.

    Receiving default: None

  3. The server portion of the e-mail address the user input in the Identity step should be placed in the Server field.

    Receive via IMAP

    1. An automatic periodic check of 10 or 15 minutes would be a sensible default.
    2. Junk filtering on incoming messages would be a sensible default.
    3. Hiding the custom command and folder namespace settings in a progressive disclosure would cut down on the clutter.

    Receiving options

    1. More poorly wrapped instructional text.
    2. The Assistant should take a stab at the outgoing server address based on the incoming server address.
    3. Use the incoming server username as the outgoing by default (I typed mine in).

    Outgoing server

    1. If an account name is already taken (thereby disabling the Forward button), tell me.
    2. Poorly wrapped instructional text.

    Account management

  4. Lastly, a pointless pat on the head.

    Final Assistant step